November 3, 2022
# 55
VA - Bing Crosby & Nat King Cole
White Christmas
2001
(Fine Tune, LLC)
Genre : Pop Vocals
This Christmas compilation CD comes with two of the most prolific singers of Christmas songs, Bing Crosby and Nat King Cole. They are the only artists presented here.
The CD cover is pretty generic. It shows a close-up picture of some Christmas tree branches decorated with gold ornaments and gold beads. Bing Crosby & Nat King Cole’s names are near the top in white letters and the CD title White Christmas is at the bottom, also in white letters. There is a dark red border all the way around the cover and some of the song titles wrap around the border, also in gold letters.
The back of the CD features the same dark red as its background and Bing Crosby & Nat King Cole’s names are at the top in white letters. Below is a numerical track listing with the performing artist, all in white letters. The same red border wraps around the back cover, just as with the front. Song titles wrap around the same as well. Some titles are repeated, and some song titles do not appear on the front.
The CD cover comes out but does not open. It is a double-sided piece of heavy paper. The back of the cover is almost an exact copy of the back of the CD, minus the red border and song titles that wrap around with it. No new information there. Bummer. (I kind of didn’t expect much anyway).
The only information we have is artist and song title. We have no writer or orchestra credits. We have no years or source of live material. Those four things would be very helpful. I was only able to track down a few of these. The rest shall remain unknown.
This is a rather inexpensive Christmas CD (that’s saying it in a nice way). Seven of the songs on here are “live” versions. When I catalog a song as live, it means there is audience applause somewhere in the song, usually at the end. That does not mean the song was performed live. Many times, the source will be from a TV special and the performer lip syncs to their newest record. So, what you get is the official record, but with applause at the end. I’d rather have just the record, if it’s going to be the record. Live recordings are okay, if they are truly live. Otherwise, I find it annoying.
There are 13 songs that feature here. Bing Crosby gets seven, and Nat King Cole gets six. Three of the 13 songs are traditional Christmas hymns or carols, and Bing Crosby sings all three. Out of the other ten songs, four are original Christmas songs and they are all sung by Nat King Cole. The other six are secular Christmas songs familiar to most listeners.
The CD begins with Bing Crosby performing White Christmas. Bing Crosby owns this song. He introduced it to the world in the movie Holiday Inn in 1942. He has recorded it many times and performed it live on TV many times. This is one of the older versions, probably around 1949 or 1950. The orchestra is probably John Scott Trotter & his Orchestra. It would be wrong to even guess the chorus, but Bing worked with the Ken Darby Singers when he worked with John Scott Trotter. This is one of the better versions out there. Very much like the 1942 version. It is a ”live” recording, probably sourced from a TV or radio Christmas special.
The 2nd song is The Christmas Song performed by Nat King Cole. And Nat King Cole owns this song. Mel Torme and Robert Wells may have written it, but Nat King Cole made it famous. This is also a live version. It’s hard to tell if this is truly a live performance or lip sync’d to the record. I believe it to be live because it doesn’t start at all like his other versions released throughout the years. I have the year as 1953 (?). But still no orchestra and with Nat King Cole, it would be hard to guess. Still, it is a great performance. If you’ve heard Nat King Cole sing The Christmas Song, which I’m sure you have at some time, this is just as endearing as his other versions.
The 3rd song is the first of the three Christmas carols. Bing Crosby performs a version of Adeste Fideles, a song he has recorded many times. This is a terrific performance. The orchestra is light, mostly strings, and the chorus is strong and is right there with Bing Crosby from the beginning. This is not a live recording, but I am unable to put a year or orchestra to it. I have four other versions of Bing Crosby singing Adeste Fideles, but this doesn’t match any of those. Bing Crosby sings this with such conviction and strength. The song begins in Latin, then after the middle break, the English lyrics are sung. The chorus oohs and aahs during the Latin section and joins Bing word for word in the second half.
The 4th song is one that I think was written specifically for Nat King Cole. When I Googled it, the only ones that came up had Nat King Cole’s name on it. Nat King Cole’s vocals on Take Me Back To Toyland, are slow and soft delivering a sentimental request to take him back to a special place shared by all children. This is a live version, but I believe it to be Nat King Cole lip syncing to a record. Nelson Riddle & his Orchestra deliver the lush arrangement, recorded in 1955.
The 5th song, I believe, is truly performed in front of a live audience. Silver Bells features a duet between Bing Crosby and Carol Richards. They released a single version in 1950 that became a Pop hit. I think they performed this version during one of Bing Crosby’s Christmas Specials. Nelson Riddle & his Orchestra And Chorus provide the lush arrangements. This version sounds exactly like the record version. I have five other copies of it, and they all sound the same. Except on this one, Carol Richards’ vocals are just barely different. I can tell by the way she phrases a word just slightly differently here than on the other recordings. Since the music sounds exactly the same, exact arrangement, I believe Nelson Riddle was Bing’s orchestra director for his Christmas special. What I don’t know is the year. Since everything sounds almost exactly the same as on the record, I would guess this was from his Christmas special in 1950.
The 6th song, A House With Love In It, is sung live by Nat King Cole. I believe it to be truly live, but this is not a Christmas song, and I have no further information for it.
Silent Night, sung by Bing Crosby, is the 9th song. It is a duet, but without any information for it, I do not know who the female singer is, nor the chorus. I have five other versions, and this doesn’t match any of those. In my opinion, it is one of the better versions of this most popular Christmas hymn that Bing Crosby produced.
A terrific original Christmas song is Mrs. Santa Claus, performed by Nat King Cole. I have three copies of this, and all are the same one. It is a “live” recording, but it is hard to tell whether it is truly live, or lip sync’d. It’s a great song supporting Mrs. Claus as the one who keeps Santa healthy and keeps everything at the North Pole organized. I’m surprised other singers didn’t dig this out and record a cover version. It’s a great original Christmas song. It’s as good as any of the other Santa songs out there.
The 9th song, Rudolph, The Red Nosed Reindeer is sung live by Bing Crosby and a wonderful small chorus of girl singers. This is a terrific version. I have no information about this, but it sounds like the late 1940s or early 1950s. Bing shares the lead with a young boy that sounds a little like Jimmy Boyd, but I cannot confirm that either. And the arrangement is with a Big Band featuring flutes, bells and a harp.
The 10th song, A Handful Of Stars, is sung by Nat King Cole. It is a sweet song, but it is not a Christmas song, and I have no information for this.
The 11th song is Jingle Bells. This is one of the many duets Frank Sinatra and Bing Crosby recorded of this song. This has the sound quality of a live performance on TV. I have the year as 1957, and it may be from Frank Sinatra’s Christmas Special from that year.
Song # 12, Santa Claus Is Coming To Town, is performed live by Nat King Cole. I have no information for this either, and it’s the only version of this song I have with Nat King Cole. This may be the only time he recorded it. The Big Band is good, the chorus is wonderful, but the song is a little cut off at the beginning. Overall, the quality is poor for this recording.
The last song, the 13th song, God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen, is sung by Bing Crosby with John Scott Trotter & his Orchestra with Max Terr’s Mixed Chorus. This is a very popular Bing Crosby Christmas hymn and shows up on a lot of Christmas compilations. The chorus is very good, providing a very solemn arrangement.
Overall, the quality of most songs is poor. I question the sources. Low budget compilation CDs are made affordable because the producers of the compilation use lower cost license sources such as transcripts from radio or TV shows. You get the same singer and the same song, but it is not the version that was released as a single and therefore does not cost as much to license.
Some songs are the official released version, played during a “live” performance, and the quality is poor. It is better to get the official released version elsewhere and without the applause at the end.
One good thing about this low budget Christmas compilation is that most of Nat King Cole’s contributions are original Christmas songs, but two of them aren’t really Christmas songs. And again, the quality is poor.
I do not recommend you rush out to buy this. Save your money and spend a little more on 1 CD by Bing Crosby singing Christmas songs, and another by Nat King Cole. You will be happy you did.
I give this CD :
*1/2*
